Luxury Caribbean Holidays

Tailor-Made Travel in the Caribbean

Every Caribbean island has its own personality. St Lucia rises out of the sea in volcanic peaks and rainforest. Barbados has a polished, walkable west coast with some of the best restaurants in the region. Jamaica has more culture, music, and character per square mile than anywhere else in the Caribbean. Grenada smells of nutmeg and cacao. The Grenadines are scattered across open water, quiet and largely left alone. And then there are the islands that don’t really want to be found — Mustique, Anguilla, Turks and Caicos — where the beach and the privacy are the entire point. That range is what makes the Caribbean so hard to choose between — and exactly why it helps to talk to someone who knows all of it.

Why choose Black Tomato for your luxury Caribbean holiday

Every member of our Caribbean team has spent time on these islands — not just passing through, but staying in the hotels we recommend, eating at the restaurants we suggest, and testing the experiences we build into your trip. That firsthand knowledge is what separates a luxury Caribbean holiday from a generic one. We listen to what you’re after — the ages you’re travelling with, the pace you want, the kind of beach that actually suits you — and design something around it. Every Caribbean itinerary we create is built from scratch.

Speak to an expert

Countries

Find your experience

Explore our Caribbean experiences based on when you want to travel and how you want to feel.

What to see and do in Caribbean

Best Caribbean Islands for Families

The best Caribbean island for families depends entirely on the ages you’re travelling with. Jumby Bay in Antigua is hard to beat for younger children — a private island, car-free, with calm water and a kids’ programme that genuinely delivers. Sandy Lane in Barbados suits families who want polish and a walkable coast. Round Hill in Jamaica has a creative, relaxed energy that works brilliantly with teenagers. And Sugar Beach in St Lucia gives you the Pitons as a backdrop with enough adventure to keep everyone engaged. Tell us the ages and we’ll point you to the right island.

Best Caribbean Islands for Couples and Honeymoons

St Lucia is where most Caribbean honeymoons start — and for good reason. Jade Mountain’s open-walled sanctuaries look directly out at the Pitons, and the island’s volcanic drama makes it feel like more than just a beach trip. St Barths brings French sophistication: exceptional dining, beautiful beaches, and an understated glamour that suits couples perfectly. Mustique is for those who want total privacy on a private island that stays deliberately off the radar. And the Grenadines — scattered, quiet, and best explored by sail — are in a category of their own.

Best Caribbean Islands for Privacy and Seclusion

Some islands don’t want to be found — and that’s exactly the point. Mustique is a private island with no paparazzi, no day-trippers, and a guest list that values discretion above everything. Anguilla has long, powdery beaches that stay remarkably quiet even in peak season. Turks and Caicos offers some of the finest sand in the Caribbean with a pace that barely registers. And the British Virgin Islands are best explored by private yacht, dropping anchor in bays where you won’t see another soul. If privacy is the priority, these are where we’ll start.

Best Caribbean Islands for Food and Culture

Jamaica is the Caribbean at its most alive — reggae, dancehall, jerk pits smoking over charcoal, and a culinary scene that runs far deeper than the resorts. Barbados has the most polished dining in the region, particularly along the west coast, with a food culture that blends Bajan tradition with world-class restaurants. And Grenada — the spice island — is where nutmeg, cacao, and rum come straight from the source. If you want a Caribbean trip built around flavour and character rather than just the beach, these three islands deliver.

Island Hopping in the Caribbean

The right combination of islands gives you contrast, not repetition. Mustique and Barbados works particularly well: total seclusion first, then the social energy of the west coast. St Lucia and Grenada pairs dramatic volcanic scenery with the quieter character of the spice island. Antigua and the Grenadines work beautifully — one of the Caribbean’s best-connected hubs leading into a scattered chain by sail or light aircraft. And Jamaica and St Barths are contrast at its most extreme: culture, music, and French-inflected glamour. We handle the logistics between islands — tell us which ones interest you.

The best of Caribbean

The Eastern Caribbean

Volcanic peaks rising straight from the sea. Spice plantations and rainforests that tumble to white sand. The 365 beaches of Antigua and the coral-fringed sailing waters between them. St Lucia’s twin Pitons catching fire at dusk. Grenada’s nutmeg and cacao, still harvested by hand. The Platinum Coast of Barbados, polished and impossibly warm. The Grenadines, scattered and largely untouched. Big drama, big beauty. All of it within reach of open water.

The Private Islands

Some places don’t want to be found. Mustique and the distinctive stillness of a private island that’s chosen to stay that way. St Barths and its very particular brand of French chic. Anguilla’s long, powdery stretches of near-empty beach. The British Virgin Islands, where the best way to explore is by sail. The Bahamas and the otherworldly blue of its shallow flats. Turks and Caicos and its reef, one of the longest in the Caribbean. These are the islands you come to disappear.

Jamaica

Jamaica doesn’t do quiet. Kingston thrums with music — reggae, dancehall, the echo of Bob Marley in every street. In the Blue Mountains, mist rolls across the coffee plantations at dawn. Down in Port Antonio, bamboo rafts drift along the Rio Grande through walls of tropical green. There’s jerk chicken smoking over charcoal. There’s rum. There’s a wildness and a warmth to this island that stays with you long after the flight home.

Jumby Bay, Antigua

The typical journey to a tropical private island likely involves multiple flight changes and long boat rides over open waters. So what if we told…
View hotel

Hermitage Bay, Antigua

Escape to an untouched Caribbean haven. At this exclusive privately-owned Antigua resort you’ll get the barefoot luxury of an eco-chic hotel with all the creature…
View hotel

Spice Island, Grenada

Spice Island Beach Resort has earned its place among Grenada's finest properties. And it's not hard to see why. Set directly on Grand Anse, the…
View hotel

FAQs

Everything you need to know about visiting the Caribbean with Black Tomato

Which Caribbean island is right for me?

Which island you visit depends entirely on what you are looking for — and getting that answer right is exactly what we do. St Lucia suits those who want dramatic scenery and a sense of adventure alongside the beach. St Barths is ideal for those drawn to French sophistication and understated glamour. The Grenadines offer an off-the-beaten-track private island experience. Turks and Caicos has some of the finest beaches in the Caribbean and exceptionally calm waters. We ask the right questions, listen carefully, and point you in the right direction — not overwhelm you with options.

Is the Caribbean a good destination for a honeymoon or romantic trip?

The Caribbean is one of the best destinations in the world for a honeymoon or romantic trip. St Lucia is our strongest starting point for honeymooners — Jade Mountain’s open-walled sanctuaries look directly out over the Pitons, and Sugar Beach sits between them on a former plantation. The island’s dramatic landscape makes it feel genuinely special rather than just a beach resort. St Barths suits couples who want sophistication and great dining alongside the romance. For those seeking total privacy, Mustique and the Grenadines are in a different category entirely. We’ll match the island and the property to what matters most to you as a couple.

Is the Caribbean good for families?

The Caribbean can be exceptional for families — but the island and hotel choice matters more here than almost anywhere else. Jumby Bay in Antigua, Spice Island in Grenada, Sandy Lane in Barbados, Round Hill in Jamaica, Rosewood Little Dix Bay in the British Virgin Islands, and Sugar Beach in St Lucia are among our strongest family options. We’ll always help you find the property that best suits the ages and interests of your group — the answer changes significantly depending on whether you are travelling with toddlers, school-age children, or teenagers.

What is the best time of year to visit the Caribbean?

For most islands, the best time to visit the Caribbean is mid-December to mid-April — rainfall is lowest, conditions are most reliable, and the region is at its best. That said, the southern Caribbean tells a different story. Islands like Grenada and the Grenadines sit largely outside the Atlantic hurricane belt, which means they can be visited year-round without the same seasonal concerns. We’ll always advise on timing specific to your chosen island and help you weigh up dates, availability, and pricing across the season.

What is the difference between all-inclusive and non-all-inclusive in the Caribbean?

In the Caribbean, all-inclusive means something quite different depending on where you stay — and it’s worth understanding the distinction before you decide. Properties like Jumby Bay, Hermitage Bay, and COMO Parrot Cay offer all-inclusive experiences, but these are intimate, high-quality retreats where the all-inclusive element simply means you can relax without thinking about the bill. Others, such as Sandy Lane or Eden Rock, operate on a room-only or B&B basis, giving you more flexibility to dine out and explore. We’ll always explain what is and is not included at each property so there are no surprises on arrival.

Can I combine two Caribbean islands in one trip?

Combining two Caribbean islands in one trip is absolutely possible — and for the right itinerary it adds real depth. Mustique and Barbados work well together — seclusion followed by the social energy of the west coast. St Lucia and St Barths offer a contrast between drama and glamour. The Grenadines lend themselves to island-hopping by nature. The practical considerations are flight routing and minimum stays — some islands require connecting flights that add meaningful travel time, and some of our preferred properties ask for a minimum of four or five nights to make the stay worthwhile. We’ll always advise on whether combining makes sense for your specific dates and interests, or whether one island done well is the stronger choice.

Why do you only feature certain hotels?

We only feature hotels that have been personally visited or vetted by our team — properties where we have strong, long-standing relationships and where we know we can deliver a genuinely exceptional experience. We’d rather recommend fewer hotels with total confidence than hand you a long list without a point of view — that’s not how we work, and it’s not what our clients come to us for.

How do you handle flights to the Caribbean?

We handle flights to the Caribbean as part of the overall trip, and it’s something we take seriously. Many islands require connections via Miami, New York, London, or other hubs, and some of the smaller islands are only accessible by light aircraft. We’ll map out the best way to get to your chosen destination, advise on connections, and arrange transfers at the other end. Getting the journey right is as much a part of the trip as the hotel.

“Using AI To Plan Travel: Black Tomato’s New Tool May Reinvent How You Book”

“The hardest parts of travel planning is getting started. The Feelings Engine makes that feel like a game worth playing”

“Many companies brag about offering once-in-a-lifetime experiences. But with Black Tomato it’s not hyperbole”

“Black Tomato is a super innovative company where the sky is the limit for their clients”

“Luxury travel company, Black Tomato, specialises in the trip you didn’t even realize you had been dreaming of”

“Black Tomato has made it a mission to keep the world of travel fresh, responsible, and exciting”

“Black Tomato is a leading luxury travel company that provides innovative and inspiring experiences”